Why U.S. Soccer’s move to name Emma Hayes to the USMNT hiring committee makes sense

## Emma Hayes’ Role in the USMNT Coaching Search

U.S. Soccer has included U.S. women’s national team head coach Emma Hayes in the committee tasked with finding Mauricio Pochettino’s successor as head coach of the U.S. men’s national team (USMNT). While it is unusual for one senior national team coach to help select another, Hayes’ experience makes her a valuable voice in the search.

Pochettino is leaving the USMNT for Manchester United. U.S. Soccer CEO J.T. Batson and COO Dan Helfrich will lead the hiring process alongside the federation’s soccer leadership team, including assistant sporting director Oguchi Onyewu. Hayes will contribute a technical perspective to the decision.

Her appointment reflects the federation’s emphasis on collaboration—and the need to find a coach who can build on the team’s existing progress.

## Hayes Brings Valuable Tactical Expertise

The next USMNT coach will inherit a team with an established playing identity, a mix of experienced players and emerging talent, and time to prepare for future competitions. That makes continuity an important consideration in the search.

Hayes has spent more than two decades coaching across the United States and Europe. Her teams have often combined attacking intent with tactical flexibility, giving her a useful perspective on how a candidate’s style could suit the USMNT player pool.

Pochettino’s approach was not without mixed results, but his high-energy, attack-minded soccer showed promise with the U.S. squad. Hayes can help the hiring committee assess which coaches might preserve the strengths of that approach while bringing their own ideas to the team.

Hayes said her role is to support the process through a technical lens, drawing on her experience as a national team coach and her knowledge of the game. Her input may help U.S. Soccer evaluate not only a candidate’s reputation, but also how their tactics could translate to the players available.

## Experience With the Demands of International Coaching

Coaching a national team differs significantly from managing a club. International coaches have limited time with players, who spend most of the season with their clubs. That requires careful planning, clear communication and the ability to make an impact during short training windows.

Hayes understands those demands firsthand. She has described the challenge of working with players for a brief period before they return to their clubs, a schedule that requires national team coaches to be efficient and adaptable.

Although the USMNT and USWNT jobs are not identical, Hayes can help the committee consider the realities of leading a senior national team. Her experience offers insight into the balance between preparation, player relationships and performance expectations.

## Hayes Understands U.S. Soccer’s Ambitions

Hayes’ record also aligns with the federation’s goal of hiring a coach capable of matching its ambitions. Before taking charge of the USWNT, she built a decorated career at Chelsea, winning eight league titles and seven cups. She then led the United States to Olympic gold at the 2024 Paris Games, just months after officially starting the job.

U.S. Soccer has high expectations for the men’s program, including reaching its first World Cup quarterfinal since 2002. The federation also hopes to contend for a medal in men’s soccer at the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics.

The next USMNT coach will need more than tactical knowledge. U.S. Soccer is looking for a candidate whose ambition matches the program’s goals, supported by the experience and ability to turn that ambition into results. Hayes’ success across club and international soccer gives her a strong understanding of what those demands involve.

## A Rare Perspective on the American and European Games

Hayes has a distinctive background for advising on the USMNT search. She began her coaching career in the United States, giving her a grounding in the American soccer landscape, and later became one of the most respected coaches in England.

That combination provides an insider’s understanding of U.S. soccer and an accomplished outsider’s view of the wider game. The hiring committee may need to weigh both perspectives as it considers candidates with different backgrounds and levels of familiarity with American soccer.

Hayes can help assess where a coach’s experience is most relevant—and what support a candidate might need to succeed in the USMNT role.

## Hayes’ Coaching Network Could Help the Search

In addition to her technical knowledge, Hayes has built relationships across the global coaching community. During her 12 years at Chelsea, she earned recognition from peers throughout English soccer and developed connections with prominent managers.

Hayes has spoken about receiving calls from former Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson and messages from coaches including Pep Guardiola and Jürgen Klopp. Those relationships do not determine who U.S. Soccer will hire, but they underline the respect she has earned within the sport.

Her network may also help the federation better understand potential candidates and the realities of the job. Still, Hayes’ value to the process goes well beyond access to influential coaches: her tactical judgment, international experience and knowledge of U.S. Soccer all make her a meaningful contributor.

## Why Emma Hayes’ Involvement Makes Sense

Including Emma Hayes in the USMNT coaching search is an uncommon move, but a practical one. She knows the demands of international management, has coached successfully in both the United States and Europe, and brings a strong record of winning at the highest levels.

As U.S. Soccer searches for Pochettino’s successor, Hayes can help the committee identify a coach whose style fits the player pool and whose ambitions match the federation’s goals. Her involvement gives the process an informed technical perspective—and may help the USMNT build on the progress already made.

Leave a Comment